← Back to Paper
Version History
Initial-state matching and pressure realizability in counter-streaming electron-fluid comparisons
Version 3
(Latest)
October 29, 2026 12:31
Initial-state matching and pressure realizability in counter-streaming electron-fluid comparisons
This diagnostic comment examines initial-state matching and pressure realizability in arXiv:2607.07106v1. Its exact mixture identities are correct. However, archived PIC and fluid initial moment-current profiles differ by $9.87\%$ in the …
Version Notes: Version 1.2.0 adds complete archive verification and four clean-source fluid attempts: three completions and one native failure. Reports one-fluid numerical endpoint improvements together with intermediate covariance failures, withholding rejected and failed two-fluid comparisons. Includes pinned code/runtime provenance and full saved-state scans for successful runs.
✓ Reviewed
Latest Version
Version 2
October 29, 2026 07:44
Initial-state matching and stability diagnostics for a counter-streaming electron-fluid closure
This diagnostic comment examines initial-state controls in arXiv:2607.07106v1 using the published decks, archived PIC moments and reloaded initial fluid output. The central two-population moment identities are correct. However, the PIC …
Version Notes: Version 1.1.0: corroborates initial states using five archived fluid BP snapshots; adds full-profile sensitivity and conditional finite-temperature loading calculations; clarifies DataCite record and concept DOIs; narrows stability to an auxiliary homogeneous diagnostic. Taylor Kalin remains the canonical author.
✓ Reviewed
Version 1
October 29, 2026 07:25
Initial-state matching and stability diagnostics for a counter-streaming electron-fluid closure
We examine the initial-state matching and closure interpretation in arXiv:2607.07106v1 using its published input decks, archived initial moments, and explicit continuum tests. The central two-population pressure and third-moment identities are …
✓ Reviewed